Mon 7 Dec 2009
When I was but a young lad my father used to play an 8 Track (yes, an 8 Track!) of Tommy Makem and the Clancy Brothers called Live at Carnegie Hall.
I always remembered that 8 Track (yes! An 8 Track!) and when I growed up (sic) into the strapping man I was briefly in my twenties I would think of it fondly. Later, in my couch potato thirties, I thought of it some more, but did nothing about it.
(I might be confused. It might be Simon and Garfunkle that was on 8 Track, and Live at Carnegie Hall on vinyl. Damn this aging memory. No matter.)
But it wasn’t until my forties that I got around to purchasing Live at Carnegie Hall on CD. I thought it was just a nostalgia purchase, a way to recapture a hint of my youth. Once purchased, though, I found myself listening to it all the time. It is a beautiful performance, full of lively music, funny music, touching music.
That album wasn’t all I knew of them. My father had other albums too. I used to take them to CJRW Radio with me back when I was a DJ. I did a six hour country show on Friday Nights called the Ranch Party, and I would often slip in some Tommy Makem and the Clancy Brothers. I remember I used to play this one song I really liked called Isn’t it Grand, Boys. I don’t remember much of it now, except that one line went: “Isn’t it grand boys, to be bloody well dead.”
One night after playing that song a regular listener called up to say that I should never play that song again. It wasn’t that they didn’t like the song, it was that they couldn’t handle the sentiment. They were of an age where perhaps they had seen too much of death, or perhaps they felt their’s was imminent, and they had yet to come to terms with it (who has?). Out of respect for this regular listener’s feelings it was with some regret that I never did play that song again.
The last of Tommy Makem and the Clancy Brothers passed away the other day, Liam Clancy. He may think it’s grand, but I don’t. Thankfully his music and that of his colleagues live on because we live in an age where though artists may pass on, their work doesn’t (necessarily). Just today I listened to Tommy Makem and the Clancy Brothers version of The Parting Glass from their performance Live at Carnegie Hall.
Good night, Mr. Clancy and friends, and joy be with you all.

